Gartner Blog Network


PC Vendors Fail to Market to Music Content Creators – Apple Gets It and Wins

by Werner Goertz  |  November 19, 2018  |  2 Comments

Content Creation has been a focus for PC vendors and their supply chain partners (Microsoft, Intel) to counter the decline of their device category. Featured use cases have been image processing (Adobe) and advanced PowerPoint (in addition to high-end gaming). PC makers have largely ignored the millions of recreational, semi-professional and professional creators of music and performance content: songwriters, performers, publishers.

Yet, the use case is compelling:

  • Real time analog-to-digital conversion requires some serious processing muscle
  • Clip editing, mixing, notating require high-res displays and a rich visual canvas
  • A software ecosystem exists in the form of DAWs (Digital Audio Workstations, such as ProTools, Ableton or OpenLabs’ Stagelight), VSTs (virtual instruments) and open libraries of clips, loops and samples.

In the meantime, Apple gets it: their cross-platform music creation app (Garage Band) is stealing the hearts and ears of musicians around the world. The MacOS / ProTools platform is the de-facto standard for serious musicians. Why? Because music recording, editing, mixing, mastering, publishing just works. In true Apple fashion, the UX is practically plug-and-play, allowing the content creator to focus on what they do best: creating content.

On Wintel PCs, different story: PC hardware and their internal (oftentimes on-mobo) soundcards refuse to talk ASIO (a driver protocol standard defined by Steinberg), resulting in horrendous real time headaches, especially when processing MIDI input signals. It is left entirely up to the user to stitch together hardware, driver, and software platforms and troubleshoot (good luck with that!) even before they can compose/record a single note of music.

Here’s what I think needs to happen:

  • PC vendors should come up with “Composer Editions”, with fully integrated, ASIO-compliant soundcards and audio instrument interfaces that are pre-configured and pre-tested.
  • Intel hardware and Microsoft OS should figure out a way to make plug-and-play interoperability easy and seamless to the user, much like Apple’s integrated platform has
  • “Composer Editions” should bundle leading “freemium” DAWs (ProTools First) or trial versions (OpenLabs’ Stagelight Trial) pre-configured and ready to rock!
  • The PC industry should leverage consumer events such as CES, and musicians’ forums such as NAMM to reach music content creators with similar levels of live demos and on-stage tutorials that are presented today for high-end gaming.

Category: 

Werner Goertz
Research Director
1 years at Gartner
21 years IT Industry

Werner Goertz is a Research Director within Gartner's Personal Technnologies team, where he covers personal devices (smartphones, PCs/Ultrabooks, tablets/ultramobiles and wearables) and IoT. A special emphasis of his research lies in the Human Machine Interface (HMI) and multimodal I/O technologies: voice/speech processing and recognition, facial recognition and eye tracking, biometrics and motion/gesture control. Read Full Bio


Thoughts on PC Vendors Fail to Market to Music Content Creators – Apple Gets It and Wins


  1. Richard says:

    Why Asio in the first place? It’s long overdue that Microsoft provides a proper audio stack like apple does for the Mac. Asio is a band-aid. It’s the OS integration that causes the Mac to just work even with cheap on-board sound devices which can be witnessed on Hackintoshes. The exact same on-board interface works beautifully (within the quality limits of the hardware) on a Hackintosh with OSX but with horrible latency running windows on the same machine.

  2. Austen Earp says:

    Thank you for this!



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.