Gartner Blog Network


Will “Facebook At Work,” Work?

by Mike Gotta  |  January 15, 2015  |  6 Comments

Last November’s speculation that Facebook was entering the enterprise social networking space was confirmed this week as the company revealed additional information about it’s Facebook at Work service. Several analysts and myself discussed how Facebook’s move into the enterprise market might play out. Our collective thoughts are shared below in a Q&A format. We’d appreciate your comments and reactions.

If you’re a Gartner client, feel free to setup an inquiry to discuss the implications Facebook at Work could possibly have for your organization.

Why would Facebook get into the enterprise space now? Is it too late?

Even though enterprise social networking has been around for several years, many organizations still struggle with adoption. We’ve learned that behavior change is difficult and deploying “social as a destination” site can create a silo disconnected from people’s everyday work activities. Over the past few years, the market has shifted emphasis of the destination site model to one where social capabilities are contextually integrated into productivity tools and business applications to provide a better sense of purpose. Strategists often believe that “social in the flow of work” alleviates behavior change challenges and helps with determining business value since the work activity typically has some type of metric.

However, this shift does not mean that there is no value in a destination site. Since employees likely use Facebook as a consumer, there is a familiarity that can be tapped into by offering an “at work” experience. A credible argument can be made that workers are more productive when they use tools that allow them to apply the same skills and literacies across digital work and life. Consumerization and BYOx trends reflect this viewpoint where organizations are becoming more receptive to managing a diversity of devices and applications. However, Facebook still needs to position its business offering in a purposeful manner.

What possible scenarios could Facebook emphasize?

We would expect Facebook to work closely with its early adopters and future partners to identify use case scenarios that illustrate practical business scenarios. If Facebook at Work is left for employees to figure out on their own as a generalized environment for ad-hoc information sharing, team collaboration, and community-building – then Facebook risks running into the same quagmire of adoption and business value issues that has burdened enterprise software vendors. Example use case scenarios include:

  • Employee onboarding
  • Alumni and retiree networks
  • Wellness programs
  • Corporate communications (such as town halls, polls, surveys)
  • Community outreach (voluntary employee groups that do social good locally)
  • Employee engagement
  • Communities specific to roles, work practices, and such
  • External activities with business partners and contractors – potentially customers down the road.

What possible role can partners play?

By getting into the enterprise business, Facebook is opening the door to additional partnerships and add-ons to its core capabilities in order to expand its overall ecosystem.  Additional solution scenarios are possible if Facebook at Work included an app store that focused on business activities. For instance, if employees could add project and document management apps then Facebook At Work can become more structured to support project management as well as the development of / response to RFP proposals.

Enterprise social networking (ESN) is a fragmented market where major vendors have been reluctant to embrace standards or move in directions that increases interoperability with competitors. The complexity of integrating with multiple large vendor players can disenfranchise smaller vendors in the market. Employees can easily find themselves with several profiles, follow models, and activity streams to track. Organizations can find themselves in a situation where they are justifiably using a few large-scale ESN deployments without a “hub” or common destination that supports cross-functional activities. If Facebook were to leave complicated business scenarios (such as those involving compliance, process management, records management) to others then it could potentially create a vibrant partner and developer ecosystem. Facebook also needs to make sure they partner effectively with the IT Organization. They need to make sure that Facebook at Work has the necessary administration and policy management capabilities to satisfy security, identity, privacy and overall management concerns.

Who is threatened then?

Vendors that lack diversity by being focused only on delivering ESN solutions could see some of their basic workloads shift to Facebook at Work. Facebook at Work could also move into mobile messaging as well. Finally, if Facebook at Work were successful, then consumer players such as LinkedIn potentially could see competition as Facebook will have the opportunity to create a large-scale collection of professional profiles.

Are there other concerns? 

Absolutely – if you look at the recent media stories regarding consumer social media players, including Facebook, involved in questionable research studies that allegedly manipulated people in some way – those issues come over into the enterprise. The anxiety employees have in their consumer experience regarding Facebook need to be addressed before an organization deploys Facebook at Work. All vendors, not just Facebook, need to address transparency and ethical aspects of their algorithms and monitoring techniques.

 

Category: collaboration  facebook  

Tags: facebook  facebook-at-work  

Michael Gotta
Research Vice President
1 year at Gartner
30 years IT industry

Mike Gotta is a Research Vice President for collaboration and social software at Gartner Research. He has more than 30 years of experience in the IT industry, with 14 of those years spent advising business and IT strategists on topics related to collaboration and social networking as an industry analyst. …Read Full Bio


Thoughts on Will “Facebook At Work,” Work?


  1. The arrival of Facebook @ Work is great signal for the ongoing development of the social business realm.

    With regard to their entry into a relatively crowded market, I use a three-question jobs-to-be-done test that I use for any new idea.

    1. Targets real job of enough people?

    I’ll say ‘yes’ to this one. Getting access to others’ knowledge and updates is part of daily work work for millions. It’s real jobs-to-be-done (collaborate, build an idea or project, access knowledge) that many people and organizations have.

    2. Better than current solution?

    Does the new thing provide better outcomes than the current solution? And just a little bit better. The idea has to overcome natural risk aversion and entrenched habits to displace the incumbent.

    It’s not clear thus far that Facebook @ Work passes this test. Mike, you allude to one possibility:

    “A credible argument can be made that workers are more productive when they use tools that allow them to apply the same skills and literacies across digital work and life.”

    I’m not entirely sure that’s the clear differentiator vs. the likes of Jive, IBM Connections, Yammer, SAP Jam, Slack, etc. But we haven’t seen all that is on offer from Facebook @ Work yet.

    3. Is the value of the better outcomes better than the costs of the idea to the customer?

    This test asks you to put yourself in the customer’s shoes. Customers in this case are both organizations and end user employees. Costs are a holistic factor. Not just cash paid. But changes in operational routines. Introduction of new behaviors that are not desired.

    You hit on a big cost that must be borne by anyone electing to go with FB @ Work in your section on Are there other concerns? Surely there will be some skepticism about having FB holding the company’s information.

    The various factors in the answers to those three questions are ones I’m watching.

    Hutch

  2. […] Mike Gotta at Gartner: Will “Facebook At Work,” Work? […]

  3. Ed Krebs says:

    One question will be – will Facebook join in the W3C standards efforts for social technology? So far I haven’t seen interest from them. While enterprises surely have monolithic, vertical applications that don’t play well with each other, if social is meant to stitch a company together in a new and better way, shouldn’t it play well with others?

  4. Mike Gotta says:

    @Ed: I have not seen enough progress and practical application of the W3C effort to be that optimistic. What I have seen are vendors “in the wild” (in actual client situations) be very reluctant to work together to provide that type of integration.

    This market is several years old. It is in a very fragmented state where vendors are more interested in displacing each other than interoperating with each other. I would love to see it – but I am more skeptical.

  5. Mike Gotta says:

    @Hutch: See my prior response. Facebook has an opportunity to actually “be the adult in the room” if – and I stress “if” – they are clear about the extend into which they want to move into the enterprise space.

    Facebook does not have to “win it all” – they can define a very specific set of workloads that support a fairly well-defined set of use case scenarios and leave it to partners and 3rd parties to extend beyond that into more complicated business scenarios that involve more complex security, compliance, process management, and so on.

    Vendors in this space are on a time clock I think. After several years of very frustrating adoption, interoperability, and business value efforts, customers are going to move onto more pressing challenges.

    Facebook at Work could be a failure – there are plenty of ways for the vendor to misplay this opportunity. But if I was a vendor that provided a generalized solution that was not tied to “real work” I would be a little nervous about a scenario where Facebook at Work gains a small but defined threshold that in turn is extended by partners.

    But again, it’s early, and there are lots of way to fail.

  6. I’ve been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or blog posts
    in this kind of space . Exploring in Yahoo I eventually stumbled upon this site.
    Reading this info So i’m satisfied to express that I have an incredibly excellent uncanny feeling
    I found out just what I needed. I such a lot without a doubt will make sure to do not omit this website and provides it a look regularly.



Comments are closed

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.