Gartner Blog Network


The Lack of Wisdom of Crowds

by John Pescatore  |  November 21, 2008  |  6 Comments

Today my 401k portfolio is worth about 50% less than it was a year ago. I don’t want to even estimate the value of my house but it is probably worth at least 20% less today than a year ago. A year ago the “wisdom of the crowd” way overvalued my net worth, today it way undervalues it – or at least I hope so, the crowd may still be fine tuning its “wisdom”.

Now, the law of averages and regression to the mean say that the crowd will end up pretty wise in the long run – but imagine making a decision based on the “wisdom of the crowd” at any individual point in time. In fact, what always happens is that when the crowd decides some course of action is wise (like taking out home loans you can’t afford or betting that the hot dice roller at the craps table will  make that eight the hard way) it almost invariably turns out that the crowd was dead wrong – this is why contrarians have made good livings betting against the crowd.

Gartner’s hype cycle construct illustrates this effect very well.  The hype cycle shows how wrong the wisdom of the crowd is most of the time.

 

Gartner's Hype Cycle

Gartner's Hype Cycle

Security is not immune to the “wisdom of the crowd” herd mentality, though the best security programs I’ve seen tend to be run by teams of people who have a strong cynical and contrarian streak. Ellen Messmer of Network World recently wrote a nice piece where she asked a number of security people about some popular security myths – take a look. 

I leave you with yet another sports analogy (and yet another apology to those of you outside the US who believe football is actually a game where you actually kick a ball with your foot): who is more wise: the football coach who kicks the field goal to tie the game, or the shouting crowd yelling for him to go for the touchdown to win? By wise I mean: who would you pay to make the right decision?

Additional Resources

View Free, Relevant Gartner Research

Gartner's research helps you cut through the complexity and deliver the knowledge you need to make the right decisions quickly, and with confidence.

Read Free Gartner Research

Category: 

John Pescatore
VP Distinguished Analyst
11 years at Gartner
32 years IT industry

John Pescatore is a vice president and research fellow in Gartner Research. Mr. Pescatore has 32 years of experience in computer, network and information security. Prior to joining Gartner, Mr. Pescatore was senior consultant for Entrust Technologies and Trusted Information Systems… Read Full Bio


Thoughts on The Lack of Wisdom of Crowds


  1. Andrew says:

    The hype cycle is explored even further, with lots of examples, in the new book by Gartner analysts Jackie Fenn & Mark Raskino called “Mastering the Hype Cycle”. Here’s a link for more information http://www.gartner.com/hypecycle

  2. Greg Young says:

    David Freedman piublished one of the best known counter arguments to the Crowd/Wisdom piece – The Idiocy of Crowds

    http://www.freedman.com/idiocy.html

  3. Anthony Bradley says:

    What is a crowd? Surowiecki in “The Wisdom of Crowds” and Howe in “Crowdsourcing” both make it clear that diversity and independence are critical to the wisdom of the crowd. “Wisdom of the Crowds” does not mean that ALL crowds are wise. When members of a crowd begin influencing each other en mass then the wisdom of crowds turns to mob mentality.

    This is critcal to successful social applications and gaining business value from communities. Not all crowds are created equal and understanding the crowd and how it might evolve is a major success factor.

    What crowd are you talking about; homeowners, home buyers, stock buyers, stock brokers, lenders? A crowd, for the purposes of wisdom, must be bounded and defined.

    This really isn’t a “Wisdom of the Crowds” scenario. There is no crowd. Macroeconomic theory is much more appropriate here.

  4. If you start handpicking the “crowd,” then it isn’t a crowd anymore. Diversity and independence, sure -that’s a crowd. That’s the crowd that leaps to overinflated expectations, and falls into the trough of disillusionment – the same crowd that drives market bubbles, the same crowd that falls for hoaxes, the same crowd that believes Daylight Savings Time reduces energy use despite constant studies showing the opposite.

    A social community is just a gathering of people with something in common – bounded that way, there are similar demonstrations of lack of wisdom. Soccer match attendees come to mind…

  5. […] NB:  The figure above was originally provided with a post, The Lack of Wisdom of Crowds. […]

  6. […] the fact that data analytics was right at the top of the peak of overinflated expectations on the Gartner hype cycle and looked forward to moving over to the plateau of productivity.  This was worrying as it sort of […]



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.