Gartner Blog Network

The (Possible) Tax Advantages of Bartering with Information

by Doug Laney  |  August 10, 2014  |  Submit a Comment

As you swipe your loyalty card at the grocery store, the register automatically discounts certain items in your basket as they pass by the scanner. But is it really a discount? Of course the store advertises that you will receive discounts by signing up for and using a loyalty card. But is it really because you’re loyal? Do you get bigger discounts the more often you shop? Not likely. Perhaps the loyalty card is encouraging loyalty, but heck, you can obtain one from any major grocer. Therefore, it seems there’s something more going on here than just a loyalty-based discount.

In reality, “loyalty-based discount” is code for “free food in exchange information about you and your purchase.” More than your loyalty, grocers and other and merchants with similar programs are after your data.

money coming from computer screen 2

The Information Economy Matures

Over three decades ago FedEx’s CEO Fred Smith proclaimed that “The information about the package is just as important as the package itself.” Since then, this realization and mindset has swept across every corner of commerce. Recently, we see companies purely in the business of accumulating and selling data with stratospheric valuation multiples. But why should they be the sole purveyors of data? The grocer “loyalty” example has been around for decades, but it’s a B2C (business to customer) model. Many businesses leaders today are realizing that this model can be extended to B2B (business to business) scenarios as well.

Most notoriously, retailers and, yes, grocers such as Dollar General, RiteAid and Kroger have made certain data sets commercially available to partners, suppliers and others for a fee. Kroger generates an impressive $100M annually in incremental revenue this way. Indeed, businesses in nearly every sector from telecommunications to energy to manufacturing to financial services have sought Gartner’s counsel on forming internal efforts to package, productize, price and promote their own information products. And as you would expect, over the past few years, information marketplaces (e.g. Microsoft Azure, ProgrammableWeb, The Data Exchange, Quandle) have emerged as Ebay-like matchmakers for sellers and buyers of data. Oh yeah, even Ebay itself has gotten in on the action, with a new category for “information products.”

Not Accounting for What Counts in Information Barter Transactions

But before we get overly excited about and fixated on selling data for cash, let’s get to the real fascinating part: taxation. Yes, taxation. Back to our grocer and you. Remember, you’re trading information about you and your purchase in exchange for free food, not cash. According to generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), discounted transactions are recorded at the value of the money exchanged, not the cost of goods. Cash is king in these transactions. However, if we presume or demonstrate that the grocer is monetizing the incremental data received by virtue of a personally-identifiable loyalty card being used, then the transaction (or part of it) ostensibly becomes a barter transaction. Stay with me now…

Barter transactions are recorded by both parties based on the value of the good or service received, yet there’s no requirement that both parties perceive the same value for what they have received. Here’s the rub: data has no value according to the accounting profession. That’s right, despite what 80% of business executives surveyed by Gartner believe, your a company’s information assets are not assets at all–at least and quite conveniently by neither the accounting profession (e.g. FASB, IFRS, AICPA, IAS) nor government revenue services (e.g. IRS). Even for companies like ACNielsen and S&P that long have been purveyors of data, and more recent ones like Google, Facebook and Twitter, their vast storehouses of information assets are nowhere to be found on their balance sheets.

Therefore, if you receive information in return for providing any good or service, arguably, this value of the transaction for accounting and tax purposes could be recorded as zero or negligible. Now you may not want to find yourself in a position of arguing this with an IRS auditor or tax court, but it’s certainly interesting to note how the everyday grocery transaction is an indicator for what could or should be in store for your data. Regardless the possible tax advantages or not, bartering with or for data unquestionably opens up entirely new avenues of commerce, even for traditional businesses. Welcome to the wondrous world of infonomics.

This piece originally appeared, in part, in Forbes:  The Hidden Tax Advantage of Monetizing Your Data

Follow me on Twitter @doug_laney


For more on infonomics:

The Hidden Shareholder Boost From Information Assets, Forbes

Six Ways to Measure the Value of your Information assets, TechTarget/SearchCIO

Infonomics Treats Data as a Business Asset, TechTarget/SearchCIO

Improving the Value of Customer Data Through Applied Infonomics, Gartner Research

The Hidden Tax Advantage of Monetizing Your Data, Forbes

How Organizations Can Monetize Customer Data, Gartner Research

Predicts 2014: Innovating With Information Will Demand New Data, Organizations and Ideas, Gartner Research

To Twitter You’re Worth $101.70, Gartner Blog Network

Twitter’s Secret Nest Egg is in Plain Sight, Gartner Blog Network

Infonomics: The New Economics of Information, Financial Times

Putting a price on information: The nascent field of infonomics, Interview in SearchCIO

Predicts 2013: Information Innovation, Gartner Research

The Birth of Infonomics and the New Economics of Information, Gartner Maverick Research

Toolkit: Assessing Key Data Quality Dimensions, Gartner Research

Introducing Infonomics, Gartner Research

An Introduction to Infonomics, interview in Information Age

Infonomics-The Practice of Information Economics, Forbes

Extracting Value from Information, interview in Financial Times (requires free registration)

To Facebook You’re Worth $80.95, Wall Street Journal

Tobin’s Q & A: Evidence of Information’s Real Market Value, Gartner Blog Network

Infonomics, Wikipedia

Infonomics Discussion Group on LinkedIn


Additional Resources

View Free, Relevant Gartner Research

Gartner's research helps you cut through the complexity and deliver the knowledge you need to make the right decisions quickly, and with confidence.

Read Free Gartner Research


Tags: accounting  big-data  data-value  economics  infonomics  information-innovation  information-management  information-strategy  information-value  

Doug Laney
VP and Distinguished Analyst, Data & Analytics Strategy
12 years at Gartner
30 years in IT industry

Doug Laney is a research vice president and distinguished analyst with Gartner. He advises clients on data and analytics strategy, information innovation, and infonomics (measuring, managing and monetizing information as an actual corporate asset). Follow Doug on Twitter @Doug_Laney...Read Full Bio

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.