Gartner Blog Network


PCoIP vs. ICA/HDX: Gavle, Sweden to New Jersey, USA

by Chris Wolf  |  October 21, 2010  |  Comments Off on PCoIP vs. ICA/HDX: Gavle, Sweden to New Jersey, USA

This post is the fourth in my series “PCoIP vs. ICA/HDX: A Simple Experiment.”

Last Wednesday I flew from Copenhagen to Stockholm, and then drove with my Gartner colleagues to a hotel in Gavle, Sweden, which was close to where we would meet a client the next day. I didn’t have much time to work with my virtual desktops while at VMworld Europe; that was mainly due to the fact that Internet connectivity was not working at my hotel.

Last Tuesday I used my VMware View client while listening to the conference keynote. During the keynote, I used TweetDeck in my View virtual desktop to tweet my thoughts. The conference Internet connectivity was surprisingly solid; I only had 117 ms latency back to my office lab. VMware View and the PCoIP protocol performed extremely well. At one point during the keynote, I opened this video on my View desktop. The video played without missing a beat. Alessandro Perilli was seated next to me and he too was impressed by the results.

Fresh off a solid performance at VMworld, I was excited to compare VMware View and Citrix XenDesktop from my hotel in Gavle. The hotel’s internet connectivity was reliable, but slow. I measured 208 ms latency and 265 Kbps bandwidth to my office lab.

The VMware View desktop connected without a problem and performance when adding a comment to a Word doc was OK. There was a slight delay between my keystrokes and when the text appeared on screen, as you’ll see in the video. PCoIP struggled when I tried to launch Internet Explorer from the start menu. It took several seconds for the menu to load before I was able to click on the IE shortcut. Once the flash application loaded in IE, performance was pretty good.

View 4.5 PCoIP over 208 ms latency

XenDesktop fared slightly better with Microsoft Word. There was also a slight delay with text entry, but I found it better than PCoIP. You’ll notice a greater difference with the Start menu navigation. With ICA/HDX, the response was almost immediate. Opening the browser and working with the Flash application was pretty good.

XenDesktop 4.0 SP1 over 208 ms latency

Category: client-virtualization  

Tags: citrix  vmware  

Chris Wolf
Research VP
6 years at Gartner
19 years IT industry

Chris Wolf is a Research Vice President for the Gartner for Technical Professionals research team. He covers server and client virtualization and private cloud computing. Read Full Bio




Comments are closed

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.