Is 15 minutes a mere instant or an eternity? Is getting an alert 15 minutes after it was first generated fast enough? And the opposite question: is 15 minutes of MSSP-side alert triage enough to make sure that the alert is relevant, high-priority and high-fidelity? Indeed, spending too little time leads to poor quality alerts, but spending too much time on quality alerts leads to the attacker achieving their goals before the alert arrives and is acted upon.
So, yes, I did speak with one MSSP client who said that “15 minutes is too late for us” and another who said that “an MSSP cannot do a good job qualifying an alert in a mere 15 minutes” (both quotes fictional, but both “inspired by a real story”).
The answer to this – frankly not overly puzzling – question is again security operations maturity. On one end of the spectrum we have folks who just “don’t do detection” and rely on luck, law enforcement and unrelated third parties for detection (see this for reference). On the other, we have those with ever-vigilant analysts, solid threat intel and hunting activities for discovering the attackers’ traces before the alerts even come in.
As we learned before, security chasm is very strong in this area.
Therefore, a meaningful MSSP SLA discussion cannot happen without the context of your state of security operations.
For example, if you …
- … have no operation to speak of and plan to hire an intern to delete alerts? You can accept any alert SLA, [SAVE MONEY!!! GET YOUR ALERTS BY SNAIL MAIL! CARRIER PIGEON OK TOO! :-)] whether it is at the end of the day, or even a week. If you have no plan to ever act on a signal, a discussion of the timing of action is senseless.
- … can act on alerts when really needed, and will probably scramble a response if something significant happens? Look for a few hours or similar timing, and limit alerts to truly critical, “incident-ready” ones.
- … have a defined security monitoring/response function that is equipped to handle alerts fast? Aim at up to an hour for significant alerts and others maybe at the end of the day.
- … possess a cutting-edge security response operation? Push your MSSP partner to 15 minutes or less – for the best chance to stop the attacker in his tracks. Set up a process to review and process alerts as they come, and refine the rules on the fly. Respond, rinse, repeat, WIN!
The key message is: you don’t want to pay for speed that you won’t be able [or don’t plan] to benefit from. If security alerts will sit in inboxes for hours, you don’t need them delivered in minutes.
Now, what about the SLAs for various management services, such as changing NIDS rules and managing firewalls? SLAs play a role here as well, and – you guessed it – what you need here also depends on the maturity of your change management processes… Some people complain that an MSSP is too slow with updates to their security devices, while others know that MSSP does it faster than they can ever do it.
Blog posts related to this research on MSSP usage:
- Acting on MSSP Alerts
- MSSP Client Responsibilities – What Are They?
- Find Security That Outsources Badly!
- Challenges with MSSPs?
- How To Work With An MSSP Effectively?
View Free, Relevant Gartner Research
Gartner's research helps you cut through the complexity and deliver the knowledge you need to make the right decisions quickly, and with confidence.Read Free Gartner Research
Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.