Andrea DiMaio with this post is trying to quell my excitement over Obama’s leadership in social software. He and I work together pretty closely on government and Web 2.0 (I focus more on the US while he covers the world). But I have to tell him that it won’t be easy to quell my excitement 🙂 Definitely not by pointing out the usual challenges of building a productive community. As my Dad always told me, “If it is too easy then it probably isn’t worth doing.”
Certainly it will be challenging. Growing and maintaining a productive community is very difficult. This particular effort may not be very effective. However, the Presidency is about leadership and he is showing leadership here. As you know, there are literally millions and millions of ways federal, state, and local governments can benefit from more sharing, collaboration, and community involvement. Some of them will be easier and some will be almost impossible.
If this particular effort fails to deliver transformational results in the long run but spurs numerous successes through its leadership then it will still be a tremendous success.
So I do say, “Let’s get excited about this example of leadership in government trying to do things differently and to take advantage of new transformational ways of collaborating.” If we do get excited about it then we will participate and it just might work.
If we treat it as just another governmental program to present the appearance of change then surely it will fail. That is part of the beauty of the social movement. It is primarily up to us (the people) to make this successful.
If I were President Obama I would not open it up to the entire public. I would randomly select say a million or so citizens as my “Citizen Advisory Community.” To remain in this community you must be active. If you are not active then you will be replaced (random again).
This would Andrea’s first two issues. The third one is a matter of Presidential usage and discovery capabilities. The Administration does not need to expose all possible decisions up for community feedback or try to gather everyone’s ideas. I would advise them to get more specific and targeted in soliciting feedback. Technology can easily help citizens find what they are interested in.
The challenges Andrea outlines (and there are many more) are not unique to this social implementation. All large communities deal with these or similar challenges. They are surmountable and have been overcome by many organizations. Whether the Obama administration can conquer them will be interesting and important to watch. I think we will learn a great deal from their leadership.
What do you think? What is your advice the new administration?
The Gartner Blog Network provides an opportunity for Gartner analysts to test ideas and move research forward. Because the content posted by Gartner analysts on this site does not undergo our standard editorial review, all comments or opinions expressed hereunder are those of the individual contributors and do not represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management.