Gartner Blog Network

If You Torture The Data Enough, It Will Confess Anything

by Andrea Di Maio  |  June 29, 2009  |  3 Comments

A former colleague of mine, Paolo Magrassi, used to say this when challenging benchmarking reports or statistics or quantitative analysis. His words came to mind after I read Casey Coleman’s latest post on her blog. I like her blog as she provides an authoritative, yet informal view of events that affect the federal government. In her latest post she mentioned Vivek Kundra’s vision of government “open by default”, i.e. data from federal agencies should be published and publicly available, unless privacy and security considerations prevent from doing so.

In my blog I’ve covered the theme of open government data many times, since when the US President issued his memo setting the scene for this.

There is one point that Casey makes and I do not entirely agree with. She says that open by default will remove the usual problem of selection bias (i.e. the self selection of individuals who decide to participate in a survey or an experiment) by allowing all American citizens to actively participate in mashing up their own data in ways that they determine. I do agree in principle, but I am more skeptical about many Americans (or Canadians, or Australians or French or….) having a compelling interest for doing their own mashups. In most cases, mashers will be businesses, other government agencies, associations, communities, who have a purpose for mashing up.

And what could that purpose be, if not to prove a particular point or sell a new product or service, or influence the public opinion on certain topics? Isn’t this something that political parties, unions, industrial associations, consumer advocacy groups, the press have always been doing? Sure, open by default will empower more actors to leverage data, but at the end of the day they won’t do so for fun, but for a “business” interest of sort.

Do not get me wrong. I think that open by default is great and, living in a country where many media are directly or indirectly controlled or influenced by government, I’d love to see somebody pursuing an open by default policy.

I just think that people need to set their expectation right and accept that, as Paolo said, if somebody tortures the data enough (open or not), it will confess anything.

Additional Resources

View Free, Relevant Gartner Research

Gartner's research helps you cut through the complexity and deliver the knowledge you need to make the right decisions quickly, and with confidence.

Read Free Gartner Research

Category: open-government-data  

Tags: government-20  gsa  vivek-kundra  

Andrea Di Maio
Managing VP
19 years at Gartner
33 years IT industry

Andrea Di Maio is a managing vice president for public sector in Gartner Research, covering government and education. His personal research focus is on digital government strategies, open government, the business value of IT, smart cities, and the impact of technology on the future of government Read Full Bio

Thoughts on If You Torture The Data Enough, It Will Confess Anything

  1. Nick Jones says:

    I agree Andrea. I would much rather have a government that was trustworthy and reliable and got on with the job of administering the country in an effective an unobtrusive manner. I have better things to do than mash up government data, it would be great if I didn’t have to worry about the fine grained details of govermnment, and my government only bothered me when a significant strategic decision had to be made. Cynically I suspect the main driver for individual citizens to mash up government data is because they need to monitor governments which aren’t reliable enough to be left alone to do their job. Which is rather sad. I guess that “open by default” is a good idea, but I wish it wasn’t so necessary.

  2. […] ← If You Torture The Data Enough, They Will Confess Anything […]

  3. […] Obama is rapidly affecting all layers of government. Messages about “open data“, “transparent by default” or “cloud computing” have mobilized formidable brainpower across government. […]

Comments are closed

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.