Google inspires and frustrates, leads and lags, marches to the beat of a different (non-enterprise) drummer and wants everyone (including enterprises) to love and adore it.
What a mix! I have been looking at Google Wave and I am really, really impressed. At the same time, I have serious misgivings about whether Google understands what it needs to do to succeed with enterprises (I have research note that’s about to pop out – probably will appear around 3 June).
Wave is potentially a major disruptive discontinuity, a clean sheet design. It will be darned near impossible for vendors of existing or earlier-generation products to morph their products to effectively emulate this. Wave will force others to do new clean sheet projects.
Unfortunately, the first on the block with an entirely new, disruptive discontinuity, isn’t always the long term winner.
This is *so* refreshing and, if the design gets sticky in the consumer market, its impact will be convulsive in large enterprises. This isn’t just a new product or service. It’s a new way of working. Google’s right to focus this on consumers (not enterprises, not for the next few years).
This is not a declaration that Google will create and own “this” market. This is a declaration that we are seeing an exciting new wave of disruptive innovation, started by Google and potentiated by a new design center (people working together in a persistent and pervasive cloud).
The design may fail. Someone else may evolve and perfect it. In the end, what matters is bold innovation that addresses many of the vexing problems posed by current product offerings.
OA – office automation – was conceptualized as automating manual tasks (typing a memo, correcting the edits, duplicating it, snail-mailing it, doing calculations on a mechanical calculator, creating slides with stick on labels and high contrast film and so forth). Current email, calendar, personal productivity and similar applications are the “ultimate” expression of those late 1970’s design goals.
Google’s wave breaks the mold, sets out to do something unique. We’ll be publishing our take on the announcement and the technology mid next week (the week of 1 June 09). In the mean time, O’Reilly’s description of Wave is a really valuable introduction. This note isn’t Gartner’s take on the Google Wave. It is my personal tribute to bold, innovative, breakthrough thinking at Google. Whether it succeeds or not, it constitutes a great step forward.
What do you think?
[We published our “Vendor Rating Note” on Google 1 April. And last looked at Gmail and other GAPE components — “The State of Google Apps” in May 2008 – the piece in final editing right now is a major update to that 2008 piece.]
Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.