Mark McDonald

A member of the Gartner Blog Network

Mark P. McDonald
GVP EXP
8 years at Gartner
24 years IT industry

Mark McDonald, Ph.D., is a group vice president and head of research in Gartner Executive Programs. He is the co-author of The Social Organization with Anthony Bradley. Read Full Bio

Coverage Areas:

Situation is the next step beyond service or solution

by Mark P. McDonald  |  January 27, 2012  |  3 Comments

Value creation and innovation come from thinking in new ways about organizational offerings.  Over the last 50 years there has been a progression from offerings based on products (things that you use in your life), to those based on selling solutions (products that we use for you) to selling services (that you incorporate into your value chain).  That progression, shown in the figure below, begs the question – what will we have next?

That is the question business leaders are working their way through.  We already know a few things as we try to define a world ‘beyond service’.  Here are a few things that I believe we will need to incorporate.

  • It will have a deeper connection to the individual, their goals and needs
  • It will be delivered via a blend of communications and computing technologies
  • It will have a social component
  • It will support customer self expression
  • It will incorporate location and condition into its value proposition
  • It will evolve rapidly
  • It will not fit into any readily available category
  • It will require significantly more and different data then we have now, used in different ways
  • Suppliers will not define it so much as by a consensus of consumers and interested parties.

So what do you call something that is personal, technological, social, customizable, unique, informational etc.  The name is something that goes beyond a product or service, or product/service, or even the notion of ‘prosumers’ advocated by Don Tapscott.  It’s more than a facility or a platform like Facebook or your bank.

One way to think about it is to call it a “SITUATION.”

Situation could be the term for a new set of offerings that create value in the world of digitized, social, networked, personal, peer influenced world.  The idea behind a situation is to capture something that is more than providing a ‘service in context’ that type of smarter approach may be a stepping-stone, but it still more about using information to slot customers into predetermined service scenarios than really addressing the situation.

Why do we need a designation of something beyond service?

Service replaced the idea of solutions as customers wanted to leverage our resources, assets, knowledge and products into extending their value propositions.  Services freed companies from having to replicate functions that were not essential to their value creation – think FedEx or UPS in logistics, Credit Cards in Accounts Receivable etc.  These services quickly came together and are now a standard of competitive strategy.

But what happens after you give people services?  You could sell them smaller services or integrate services into larger bundles or you could think of what is the next addressable frontier in terms of creating unique and sustainable value.  Addressable expressed in terms of the ability of business and technology infrastructure and substructure that makes it possible to do something new or at a price point or at a scale or at all three that was not feasible before.

Take the characterizations mentioned above and you can think of situation as the totality of them rather than simple combinations.  Some will say so what, are not the following forms of situation:

  • Context or ‘smart’ situations = service + information analytics (data, Bi)
  • Location situations = service + device location information (foursquare)
  • Social situations = service + social media (web casts, move on, etc.)
  • Event situations = service + social media + location (concert or flash mob)
  • Etc.

Yes, but we need to push beyond that, because when we do we get a definition of something that is unique to the individual and therefore a source of unique value and competitive advantage.

A situation is about a broader definition of customer need.  Need in terms of a situation exists at a point, place, condition, emotion in time.  While that comes and goes and no one is ever the same, situations are commonly understood, think situation comedy or the phenomenon of schadenfreude and you get the idea.

People are already trying to integrate and support situations on their own

You can already see situations forming as people surround themselves with sets of disparate but related technologies to build support for their situations.  Recently I was out with my son, who is working on the east coast.  We were driving in his car, his GPS was plugged in, his cellphone one, and we were running errands based on recommendations he received from Yelp!

The idea of situation as something beyond service became apparent when we changed plans, the situation changed and the value of our prior plans and preparation dropped considerably.  I would up, reassembling the situation on the GPS (new location), the phone (Texting people) all based on new recommendations from Yelp! Accessed via the smart phone.

Thinking about the future of value creation beyond service opens the door to new competitors, value propositions and opportunity.  So as you put your strategies and plans to the test for this year and the next five years or so, ask yourself are we providing products, selling services, sure but what are we doing with the situation.

3 Comments »

Category: Innovation Social Media Social Organization Technology     Tags: , , ,

3 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Education ERP Consultant   January 27, 2012 at 8:17 am

    At the same time, it is not without a number of disadvantages. Being able to weigh the two will allow a company to decide if this solution will properly meet their needs.

  • 2 Erkki Viitanen   February 1, 2012 at 3:47 am

    Hi,

    I think we are already talking about ecosystems in the mobile world. In my view, the next step could be an adaptive ecosystem which would adapt to the situations you refer to. This ecosystem would incorporate anything from widgets to process tools.

    Best regards,

    Erkki Viitanen

  • 3 Ole Schjodt-Osmo   February 5, 2012 at 5:18 pm

    Again your blog got me thinking, and this time I just can’t resist sharing some thoughts reflecting on what you wrote.  
     
    First; yes it is probably time to develop the Service concept to the next level, or at least discuss how it can be evolved one step further from being a Service. My reflections are founded on the same thinking as one could say Products evolved to Solutions, before entering to the next level becoming Services. 
     
    According to how I see it, Solutions compared to Products added integration providing a more complete integrated offer or functionality. Real value add, and a offering on a new level, came when the service providers started focusing on (or rather where allowed to focus on) the outcome and results using the Solutions. That is not only selling the drill with a sharp point, cutting edge and all necessary accessories, but providing knowledge, expertise and the actual hole in what ever substance as a: “Hole making Service”. Services have become natural elements of the value chain adding value in the most effective and efficient manner.
     
    I believe the next step will only take us half way to the next level, and my suggestion is calling the next intermediate step:  Interaction or maybe even better Engagement. Coming from Services, I see the next value add of the form to have structured ways to interoperate in unstructured processes utilising contributors both inside and outside any company. This is combining and adding value to structured Services in the value chain with human unstructured ways to interoperate, or creating the optimised experience in a given situation introducing human reasoning. 
     
    So from my perspective I guess one can call the added value on top of traditional Service offerings for a more context aware, human like reasoning and way for unstructured interaction to optimise the outcome. I prefer Engagements to Interactions as the first in my understanding has more commitment in it.

    Ole Schjodt-Osmo

Leave a Comment