Greg Young

A member of the Gartner Blog Network

Greg Young
Research VP
6 years at Gartner
22 years IT security

Greg Young is a research vice president in Gartner and the lead analyst for network security. Mr. Young has experience in IT security in product companies, and in both the private and public sectors. He spent his military career in technology security… Read Full Bio

Coverage Areas:

Little Fibs, Big Fibs, and Datasheets

by Greg Young  |  September 25, 2008  |  Comments Off

A lot of the datasheets for network security products have made it really hard for customers to conduct an apple-to-apple comparison.  I’m not talking about the overall IT industry practices with datasheets.  In the last 24 months, especially in the areas of firewall and IPS throughput,  a number of companies have started listing uninspected port throughput as the rating for the appliance, or seemingly employing a random number generator. 

This usually is a sign that the vendor has lost sight of their customers and gotten into a spiral with competitors.   Their competitors may be scared for a day or two until they get their product into their lab, but then they have a legitimate criticism they can use in sales. And guess who is grumpiest – customers. 

If a customer wants to buy 100mbps of firewall, they want to look at 100 mbps products.  Anything else only leaves them disappointed. 

Vendors – don’t apologize for specs, be tempted to nudge up some ratings, or list the port type as the throughput.  Customers – reward honest specs,  and push back if you are sold a box that underdelivers.  And, Gartner customer, call us before you make a netsec buy and I can help make sure your short list has the right products and models on it.

Caveat datasheetum.

180px-Crossed_fingers_P1442

 

Comments Off

Category: Security     Tags: