Gartner Blog Network


Private PaaS is For Real

by Eric Knipp  |  May 20, 2013  |  2 Comments

Large enterprises are very interested in the PaaS value proposition, but much less interested in making strategic commitments to public PaaS. This is generally true of public cloud overall. Only in the SaaS area do we see substantially less durdling by our enterprise clients. My working theory is that this is mostly because popular SaaS options are a cut above their packaged counterparts in capability, usability, and spending flexibility; plus, the business won’t take no for an answer. The differentiation available in some SaaS is too alluring to ignore. 

The same has so far not proved consistently true for public cloud IaaS and PaaS. To be sure, these areas are growing; recent financial analyst AWS revenue estimates are impressive indeed. Step back a minute and let the reality sink in that the market for cloud services is at least as large as the existing market for enterprise IT (hardware, software, and hosting) itself – then, the AWS number doesn’t look nearly as big. There’s still a lot more cash burned in traditional data centers than there will be in public cloud IaaS and PaaS for some time. We can argue until we’re blue in the face about whether that’s a good thing or not, but it is what it is…

And, what IT is, at least with respect to PaaS, is a growing enterprise desire for Private PaaS. Mock it at your peril – just like private cloud, the ship has sailed and will be pulling into a harbor within an enterprise data center near you. The value proposition for Private PaaS seems compelling – an increasing number of stories suggest that Private PaaS can get you both reduced operational burden and higher developer productivity. As anybody who reads my blog knows, I think that developer productivity is a big deal.

Private PaaS is coming, but how do you adopt it if you’re the “classic” enterprise IT organization with a diverse portfolio of home-grown applications and integrations, running on what I will for the purposes of this discussion call “classic” middleware? Do you wait around until 2015 (or later) for Java EE 8 to bring you the cloudy features you’re looking for, now that we know for sure that Java EE 7 won’t have any? Or, do you just wait for your preferred IT megavendor to get around to offering you a for-real, multitenant, cloud-native, Private PaaS that goes beyond simply slapping a pre-built middleware stack onto a virtual machine?

If for your enterprise, technology is just a necessary evil, a cost of doing business, then the answer is probably yes: wait until the early movers have wrung all the new value from the PaaS model and pick it up when prices are cheap and the systems commoditized. My guess is nobody reading this blog feels that way about IT.

If for your enterprise, technology is expected to expand the business, to serve as a differentiator in your market, to deliver what MBA types like to call competitive advantage – then Private PaaS can no longer be ignored.

Category: cloud  cloud-application-platforms  private-paas  

Eric Knipp
Managing Vice President
3 years at Gartner
15 years IT industry

Eric Knipp is a Managing Vice President in Gartner Research, where he focuses on Web and cloud application development methodologies and trends. Mr. Knipp is based in Dallas, Texas. Read Full Bio


Thoughts on Private PaaS is For Real


  1. […] Gartner’s Eric Knipp said this week, “Large enterprises are very interested in the PaaS value proposition,” and he goes on to […]

  2. David says:

    Also, SaaS allows for easy customization per account. A vendor can easily change the software or add features for a specific customer…



Comments are closed

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.