Gartner Blog Network


Will Cloud Computing Expose You To Patent Infringement?

by Brian Prentice  |  November 5, 2010  |  3 Comments

Last week Horatio Gutierrez, Microsoft’s Deputy General Counsel, made some interesting comments regarding the intellectual property implications of cloud computing. One insight that I think is particularly profound is that the ability of patent holders to detect infringement is going to become much harder. That makes a lot of sense. After all, cloud computing is about the provision of IT-enabled capabilities as a service. Trying to determine if your patents are being infringed upon if they are components supporting a cloud service will very difficult.

Does that mean organizations committed to building, and exploiting patent portfolios are going to be chucking in the towel while saying to themselves, “oh well, this patent thing was good while it lasted.” Doubtful…very doubtful. In all likelihood they’ll be shifting their focus to those patents which will be easier to take advantage in a cloud computing environment. Gutierrez made exactly this point when he said:

IP to do with the user interface – the part of the service that’s actually exposed – will become more important, and will become the identity of the person providing the service. We need to go back to our toolbox of IP rights and dust off some.”

I think he’s right. And I think you – the enterprise IT organization – had better absorb this quickly. Why? Because if you think the cloud computing phenomenon is strictly about IT vendors delivering infrastructure, platform and software services to you, then you’d be missing a key part of its disruptive potential. Cloud computing enables every company – whether they’re IT providers or not – the ability to deliver their own IT-enabled capabilities. IT-enabled supply chain services, for example, might just as readily be consumed from supply chain management companies as they will be from SCM application providers that offer a cloud computing option.

The seemingly never-ending stream of patent infringement cases has largely been a sideshow for enterprise IT organizations. This has been saga played out between the IT vendors and only rarely becomes a problem outside that community. But the expanding desire of IT vendors to directly commercialize their IP portfolios will slowly start to erode the reticence they have had in pursuing organizations they currently deem as being their customers.

And here’s the thing – cloud computing, over time, will blur the lines of what it means to be an IT provider. And that means every organization becomes a potential patent infringement target for those companies with portfolios bulging with UI and design patents. The chances of stumbling into a UI-related infringement action will be very easy given both the range of overly-broad patents in this area and the serious lack of attention that most non-IT vendors pay to their own potential infringement in the realm of information technology.

Sadly this will likely drive more organizations to start building their own patent portfolios. After all, one of the most consistent motivations for organizations’ interest in creating, and growing a patent portfolio is to secure a meaningful defence against patent litigation.

The patent arms race will only continue.

Category: 

Brian Prentice
Research VP
9 years at Gartner
26 years IT industry

Brian Prentice is a research vice president and focuses on emerging technologies and trends with an emphasis on those that impact an organization's software and application strategy... Read Full Bio


Thoughts on Will Cloud Computing Expose You To Patent Infringement?


  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by MW, Cloud Blogs. Cloud Blogs said: #Cloud #Blogs Will Cloud Computing Expose You To Patent Infringement?: Last week Horatio Gutierrez, Microso… http://bit.ly/bnxHPT #TCN […]

  2. Joe Restivo says:

    I do not think Cloud computing has anything to do with patent infringement. Check out the definition & facts about it: http://www.ip-holdings.com/patent-infringement ….. It’ll be interesting to see what happens!



Comments are closed

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Gartner, Inc. or its management. Readers may copy and redistribute blog postings on other blogs, or otherwise for private, non-commercial or journalistic purposes, with attribution to Gartner. This content may not be used for any other purposes in any other formats or media. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. Gartner shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.